About Nesta

Nesta is an innovation foundation. For us, innovation means turning bold ideas into reality and changing lives for the better. We use our expertise, skills and funding in areas where there are big challenges facing society.

The role of the state in the GB energy market

Overview

Over time, the state has steered the energy market towards decarbonisation, through policies such as carbon pricing and those supporting investment in renewables. As a result, carbon emissions have fallen by 53% across the UK. However, meeting and maintaining net zero emissions across the whole economy will start to become more challenging, involving decarbonising transport, heat and ‘hard to abate’ sectors like large industry and aviation. This means the UK faces the challenge of achieving and maintaining zero-carbon power while addressing a likely increase in energy demand.

Many pieces of the puzzle needed to deliver decarbonisation are in place, and the industry has the necessary ambition to deliver this. There are three overarching problems that need to be tackled, however; greater coordination and certainty is needed; the pace of change needs to be quicker, and good value for money is essential. This is where the state has a role to play.

What’s in the report

This report by Nesta and Baringa Management Consulting, funded by the European Climate Foundation, sets out an expanded role for the state that could help to address these problems, accelerating the pace of decarbonisation, bringing down the costs of the transition, improving the resilience of the energy system and promoting economic growth.

Through several meetings with senior industry stakeholders, including the new Government, our thinking has helped to inform Government policy regarding the role of the state and the formation of GB Energy.

Recommendations

The authors set out four roles that the state needs to play:

  1. The state as a planner: introduction of a system architect that would develop an overarching strategic plan to guide technology choices and locational deployment of assets, co-optimising these choices with network development
  2. The state as a developer: undertaking a range of roles such as pre-development for large-scale assets identified in the above plan
  3. The state as an investor: carrying out a range of investment activities including investing directly into higher risk emerging technologies
  4. The state as an enabler: with actions ranging from planning system reforms that would help unlock potential projects to a new public energy procurer that would coordinate energy procurement for public bodies

If implemented carefully, the proposals set out in this report protect short-term decarbonisation while providing a strong foundation to meet the challenge of delivering economy-wide net zero emissions in the longer term.

Authors

Duncan Sinclair

Duncan is a partner and expert in energy policy and regulation at Baringa, with three decades of experience in the industry.

Ravi Gurumurthy

Ravi Gurumurthy

Ravi Gurumurthy

Group Chief Executive Officer

Ravi Gurumurthy is Group Chief Executive Officer, joining Nesta as Chief Executive in December 2019.

View profile

Lewis Heather

Lewis is a director and expert in energy market design and regulation at Baringa. He has been working on key areas of energy policy, regulation, and economics for nearly 15 years.

Andrew Chittenden

Andrew has worked as a consultant in the energy sector for 30 years and was a founding partner at Baringa. He is a non-exec at the Behavioural Insights Team.

Alex Townsend

Alex Townsend is a manager at Baringa. He has been working in energy economics, policy, and regulation for 15 years.