About Nesta

Nesta is an innovation foundation. For us, innovation means turning bold ideas into reality and changing lives for the better. We use our expertise, skills and funding in areas where there are big challenges facing society.

Clean heat: coordinating the switch street by street

The UK's approach to low-carbon heating is currently individual-led, with households making independent decisions. We propose developing a coordinated approach alongside this, enabling multiple households in an area to switch simultaneously. This voluntary approach would require attractive offers to encourage participation.

Clean heat: coordinating the transition to low-carbon heat

Using open collaboration to create a blueprint for an ambitious, coordinated approach to decarbonising homes

Heat pump install_Outside Glasgow_Feb 2023_Nesta-20

Our project explored how this could work in practice, engaging stakeholders through discussions and workshops across the UK. We aimed to understand the necessary processes and structures for planning and implementing a coordinated transition.

Stakeholders included community groups, contractors, policymakers, government officials, and manufacturers. Based on their input, we've developed a policy blueprint for this coordinated approach to low-carbon heating in the UK.

What’s in the report?

This report synthesises the policy blueprint. It illustrates the organisations, stakeholders and key stages that should be refined and considered.

The organisations involved

A coordinated switching approach is likely to involve new institutions or new roles for existing institutions. We have split the institutions needed into five groups that we call personas. We have not specified the exact form these organisations should take, but we have set out the role, skill sets and resources required for these bodies to be effective. The existing groups are national planning and governance, delivery organisation and citizens. Alongside these groups, we propose two new organisations: a national heat transition unit and local heat bodies.

An overview of the process

We break down the end-to-end policy into 5 key steps: resourcing, planning, procurement, delivery and reporting. The report outlines what each stakeholder group, or organisation, would be responsible for at each stage.

What this may look like

During this section, we dive into the details of particular sections of the policy proposal and detail how this may work, for particular stakeholders. What this actually looks like for those involved.

Findings/recommendations

This coordinated approach should aim to gradually scale up over time, complementing the individual-led approach that the UK currently uses.

To scale up a coordinated approach, we recommend the following actions as first steps:

  • Develop local heat bodies in as many areas as possible to fill the gap in heat planning and coordination at a local, granular level.
    Bodies should be built from the ground up and be flexible to accommodate the local context. The development of local bodies should build on this work, convening stakeholders to understand their requirements and ultimately de-risking rollout.
  • Pilot the development of several communal shared infrastructure schemes. The government should fund these pilots in some of the more advanced local areas, most likely to be city regions. These should vary in approach to technology, property and tenure type. These pilots should seek to understand to what extent schemes require guarantees by the government to mobilise private finance.
  • Pilot a coordinated approach to individual home upgrades. These pilots should focus on how groups of homes could benefit from switching to individual low-carbon heat sources (i.e. air source heat pumps). The pilots should understand the extent to which local government-led low-carbon heat zoning and planning is enough to signal to households and trigger action. The pilots should test commercially viable offers for collective purchasing and potential partnerships with finance providers.
  • Data gathering and feedback loops should be piloted as part of recommendations 2 and 3 above. The role of a national heat transition unit should be examined to ensure that it is providing the best possible support for delivery partners and local government. The pilot should seek to understand how information should be integrated back into guidance, playbooks and advice on the formation of teams for local governments.

Authors

Andy Marsden

Andy Marsden

Andy Marsden

Design Lead, Design & Technology

He/Him

Andy is the design lead for the sustainable future mission.

View profile
Kevin Wiley

Kevin Wiley

Kevin Wiley

Analyst, sustainable future mission

Kevin is an analyst for the sustainable future mission.

View profile
Martina Kavan

Martina Kavan

Martina Kavan

Analyst, sustainable future mission

Martina joins Nesta as an analyst for the sustainable future mission, focusing on the reduction of carbon emissions from households across the UK.

View profile